Electoralism Doesn’t Work
Even when genuine radicals are elected they are not permitted to carry out their campaign promises but must serve capital. Elections coopt dissident leaders & organizers and divert energy & resources away from direct action into pointless political action.
Four Ways Elections Undermine Dissident Movements
The electoral system coopts and weakens dissent in several ways.
The CNT and Voting
The CNT typically discouraged its members from voting, or simply ignored elections, and did not participate inside the Spanish political system. During the Spanish Civil War it compromised its principles, and the results were disastrous.
Electoralism vs. Social Movements
Effective campaigns using direct action and effective political campaigns using the ballot box tend to work at cross-purposes. Direct action and political action, when organized by regular people, tend to undermine each other.
Elections, Policy, and Reform in Twentieth-Century History
The actions of the state are contingent on factors other than who wins the election, such as the status of the economy, the use of direct action by popular movements, interaction with other states, the needs & desires of the 1%, technological changes, etc.
Why I Am Not Voting
To vote for anyone is to vote for a system in which politicians in Washington, CEOs on Wall Street, and generals in the Pentagon rule.
The Collapse of the Knights of Labor
The Knights of Labor grew to become the largest nineteenth-century labor union in the US after winning a major railroad strike in 1885. It then collapsed due to intense, sometimes violent, opposition from employers and the state.
Elections are a Scam
Who wins elections makes no difference because all politicians must do what the elite want. Elections are a scam whose function is to neutralize resistance movements and deceive ordinary citizens into thinking they control the state.
The Dead End of Electoralism
It is a mistake for radical activists to attempt to use the electoral system to achieve our goals. The way the system is set up whomever is elected must do largely the same things as his opponet(s). Elections empower the politician, not the voter.
The State, Democracy, and Autonomy
States are not neutral tools that anyone can use for any purpose; they are autonomous organizations that develop their own dynamics & interests. They are a form of elite rule.